Lib Dems Demand Apology after Labour Executive Member Deliberately Misled Residents about Station Gateway Contract
York Liberal Democrats have demanded an apology from Labour's Executive Member for Major Projects, Cllr Lomas, after she blamed the previous administration for the Station Gateway contract, despite the council confirming that the construction contract was sealed three months after Labour took office.
At the November Full Council, Cllr Lomas repeatedly suggested that the problems with the Station Gateway contract had been inherited from the previous administration, describing it as a contract signed before the 2023 election.
However, following a direct question from Liberal Democrat councillors, the council's Head of Procurement, Chloe Wilcox, confirmed in writing that the construction contract with John Sisk was sealed by City of York Council on 31 August 2023, three months after Labour took control of the council.
When challenged on this at Full Council, Cllr Lomas did not dispute the signing date. Instead, she attempted to justify her claims by arguing that the council had already been committed to the financial risks of the project in April 2023.
The Lib Dems say Cllr Lomas's claims are particularly misleading given that Labour subsequently oversaw major changes to the scheme, including fundamentally redesigning the project and abandoning the simpler design the original contract was intended to deliver.
The project has been plagued by delays, spiralling costs and serious questions about contract management. Internal audit has also raised concerns about the decisions taken during the project's delivery.
The Liberal Democrats have also criticised Labour for accusing opposition councillors of lying about bus usage figures, despite the published data supporting the figures the Lib Dems had been using.
The party is now demanding that Cllr Lomas apologise for deliberately misleading residents about the history of the Station Gateway contract.
Cllr Paula Widdowson, Liberal Democrat Deputy Group Leader, said:
"Labour are becoming increasingly desperate to distract attention from the catastrophic financial mess they have created in York, and Station Gateway is perhaps the clearest example.
"Cllr Lomas has repeatedly tried to blame the previous administration for a contract that the council's own Head of Procurement confirms was not sealed until 31 August 2023, three months after Labour took office.
"When challenged with that evidence, she didn't dispute the date. Instead, she tried to muddy the waters by talking about an earlier commitment to the project. Residents deserve a straightforward account of what happened, not an attempt to rewrite history.
"Labour inherited a project, but they made decisions about how it was delivered, signed the construction contract under their administration and subsequently made major changes to the scheme. They cannot simply blame everyone else for the consequences.
"And this isn't an isolated incident. Labour have also accused Liberal Democrat councillors of lying about bus usage, despite the published figures backing up what we have been saying.
"It is extraordinary that an administration which has presided over such a financial disaster thinks it is in a position to lecture others about honesty.
"Instead of taking responsibility, Labour are throwing around accusations and trying to rewrite the history of their own decisions.
"York deserves a council that tells residents the truth, takes responsibility when things go wrong and focuses on delivering for our city. Labour are demonstrating that they are simply not fit to lead."