Labour votes down Lib Dem motion to halt premature £1.8 million Local Plan replacement

19 Nov 2026

York Liberal Democrats have criticised Labour councillors for voting down a motion calling for the council to halt its accelerated replacement of York’s Local Plan and concentrate on delivering the homes already agreed.

 

The motion, proposed by Cllr Andrew Hollyer at Full Council, highlighted the decision to begin consultation on replacing York’s Local Plan just 19 months after it was formally adopted in February 2025.

 

The council's own April 2026 Executive report estimated that preparing a replacement plan would cost £1.8 million.

 

Liberal Democrats argued that, rather than spending millions starting the planning process again, the council should focus its resources on getting the homes already allocated built, alongside the roads, schools, healthcare, drainage and green spaces needed to support them.

 

The motion called for Labour to halt the accelerated replacement, publish a clear programme for delivering allocated housing sites and report back on the financial implications, including money already spent, future costs and potential savings.

 

It also made clear that the council would still need to meet its statutory planning responsibilities, including minerals and waste planning.

 

Cllr Andrew Hollyer, Liberal Democrat Spokesperson for Housing and Planning said:

 

“York needs more genuinely affordable homes. But we have only just agreed an ambitious Local Plan with 20,000 new homes, and instead of concentrating on delivering what we have already promised, Labour wants to start the whole process again.

 

“Residents need to see the homes already allocated actually delivered, with the infrastructure to support them. They don't need another expensive planning exercise that risks creating further uncertainty and delays.

 

“Our motion offered a practical alternative: stop the accelerated replacement, get on with delivering the existing plan and be honest with residents about the costs involved.

 

“Labour had the opportunity to support that approach and chose to vote it down.

 

“Residents deserve to know why Labour is prioritising another planning process over getting on with the homes and infrastructure York already needs.”

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.