Labour accused of hiding York's financial crisis after using childish games to block scrutiny

12 Nov 2026

Labour councillors have been accused of treating York residents with contempt after using up the time at last night's Full Council meeting to prevent a Liberal Democrat motion on financial transparency from even being debated.

 

Labour put forward more than half of its executive to speak on an earlier motion, despite it being clear that the motion was going to be rejected. The extraordinary number of Labour speakers meant that time ran out before the Liberal Democrat motion on York's finances could even be reached.

 

When Liberal Democrats proposed extending the meeting to allow the debate to take place, Labour voted against it.

 

The blocked motion would have forced Labour to be more open about its plans for the next two years, including potential cuts to local services, further council tax increases, the sale of council assets and whether the council will need to take out a government loan.

 

It comes at a time when there is no budget consultation taking place this year, leaving residents with even fewer opportunities to scrutinise or challenge the financial decisions being made in their name.

 

Liberal Democrats say Labour is presiding over the least transparent administration in York's history, with residents being kept in the dark about the scale of the financial crisis and what it will mean for their communities.

 

Cllr Nigel Ayre, Leader of the Liberal Democrat Group, said:

 

"York Labour have become the masters of hiding things from residents. They won't consult residents on the budget, they won't properly explain their plans for the city's finances, and now they are resorting to childish procedural games to stop councillors even debating the questions that matter.

 

"Putting up more than half of your executive to speak on a motion they knew would be rejected is not meaningful debate. It is a deliberate attempt to run down the clock and avoid scrutiny.

 

"Let's be absolutely clear about what Labour didn't want to discuss. What services are they planning to cut? Will Labour increase council tax by £240? Which public assets are they planning to sell off? And are they going to have to go cap in hand to the Government for a pay-day loan to keep this council afloat?

 

"These are decisions that will affect every household in York for years to come. Residents have every right to know what is being planned behind closed doors.

 

"When we tried to extend the meeting to allow those questions to be debated, Labour voted that down too. What exactly are they so desperate to avoid discussing?

 

"This is an administration that has become increasingly secretive, increasingly evasive and increasingly unwilling to be held accountable. York has never seen a council administration with such a slim majority so determined to keep residents in the dark.

 

"Residents deserve better than childish political games and a Labour administration more interested in protecting itself than being honest about the decisions it is taking.”

This website uses cookies

Please select the types of cookies you want to allow.